People who know me know I have 2 basic modes when watching a show. Either I'm completely riveted by the canon - usually this happens with HBO shows: The Sheild, The Wire, Rome, Deadwood - and I am just... floored by how happy the show makes me, how unblievably amazing it is, but at the same time, because the canon is
so awesome I don't really feel the need to do the fandom thing. I mean, I'll make graphics sometimes, but really I just... I have nothing to say because it's all said RIGHT THERE in the canon. Those tend to be the shows I like and consider myself a fan of.
Then there are shows where I think the canon blows, but that have a general idea - a plot, a character - that appeal to me and that I think could be done very well in right hands. This doesn't have to mean I think the show is bad, sometimes the format just isn't to my liking. The Stargate verse falls into this category for example (though I actually do find the Gateverse to be
absolutely awful). It has ideas and characters I would like to see explored differently. That's when I go to fandom. That's when I read and even write fanfiction and participate in things. It's funny because in those case, I couldn't technically refer to myself as a
fan of the source material - I generally think the source material sucks ass.
And then came BSG.
I hadn't actually been in a fandom for a show I was
excited about since probably Buffy. And Buffy doesn't count because I was 13 at the time and it was my first experience with fandom, period, and therefore a bit of a strange mix of everything.
And BSG became... it became the show I could
think about, really, sink into that universe and play around because it was so
rich and well crafted, but at the same time there was so much I wanted to talk about, so much I wanted to comment on and explore and imagine on my own.
I've never read fanfiction for BSG, because I love the source material too much, I just have no room in my head for anyone else's interpretation, but at the same time I've squeed and commented and discussed and analyze and oh god how I've
shipped.
BSG was probably my first fandom as an adult person. A fandom I was actually part of in some small way, that I took part in and that I considered "my own", my home base.
I began watching the show shortly after being discharged from the military. I sat at home and mostly stared at the walls and tried to get out of the shock of getting discharged back into civillian life, and then BSG popped up on my radar and I gave it a spin. I fell in love with Starbuck
immediately - a soldier! And a girl! - and Laura and Lee and Cheif and Bill... what killed me was how
utterly flawed they all were in such subtle, subtle ways.
Bill was a stereotypical Wise Old Leader Father Figure guy, but at the same time he was an emotional commander and that HAD ITS FLAWS. He didn't just love them all like his children - he also had fits of utterly disproportionate rage, just as parents do towards their children, when they did things he disagreed with.
And in Lee's speech in the flashback, we see that reaffirmed in the very last episode of the show.
The show, on the whole, overall, managed to avoid glorifying and simplifying its characters. And that's RARE. Even some shows that
start complicated end up being reduced to black and white when the creators along with the fans fall in love with the characters.
But with BSG, I never felt like the creators were catering to my tastes, or anyone's. They were doing it out of their own desire to see things unfold, they took ont eh burden of being storytellers and allowed me to be a viewer, to be childish and squeeful.
And I loved the characters so much. God. I know for some people it was about the plot, the theology, the action but for me, all that stuff was bullshit. I get a philosophical discussion several times a day in my various college classes. I have books and friends for that. What I was here for was the
characters. All I cared about was them, as people, and what they went through and what that meant to them.
Kara, who, to the VERY END of the show, one of the VERY LAST SCENES, is seen as an utterly ambivalent, complicated character. She NEVER conforms to being a good girl or a bad girl, she's just human, she's just her. Lee is never a stereotypical hero, he's hesitant and flaky and sometimes full of self deception and they are
all cowards sometimes, emotionally, personally, and bastards, and they make mistakes and just
move on because you can't make everything right and you can't always make amends. They are all such incredibly flawed, fucked up, bastards, my heart is filled with love.
BSG broke so many stereotypes, did so many things that had not been done on television before, especially not in the scifi section of American TV. As an example, check out how many female soldiers and politicians exist in the universe of the new scifi-esque NBC show Kings - a show that's been hailed as "progressive" and "liberal".
Now, don't get me wrong, BSG was not perfect. I say this as someone who's used to HBO's programming: not on issues of race or gender and not on issues of characterization and writing was BSG up the standard I wish it had been. It was still a step behind where I'd ideally have liked it go. It fucked up on some storylines, on some characters, and those issues will be part of my experience with it as well.
But it was, without a doubt, exceptional in its genre, in its time, in its niche. It restored my faith in modern American scifi TV - scifi that could talk about what I had grown up to understand scifi to be about. Human nature. Metaphors of social critique. Philosophy.
I love you show, deeply and profoundly. You were my fandom, my home. I don't know when, if ever, I'll have that again. You changed me and affected me, as a storyteller and as a viewer. You've shown me ways of doing things that others hadn't. You were kind of amazing. Kind of a lot.
It occurs to me that BSG is kind of my personal land mark. I've never known anyone in real life who was a giant Star Trek or even Star Wars fan, but I imagine that 10 years from now I'll still be that girl who, when the conversation comes up, will talk about how amazing and ground breaking and incredible and
deeply personal BSG was for me. How I still remember the old jokes and still have feelings about the characters. Still my own criticisms and moments of squee. I'm sure the day is not far when I'll have sunk back into the routine of "ordinary" television, that I'll open up my BSG episodes and sigh and remember how
awesome it was to have this show on the air.
I love you show. At the end of the day, I really do.
<3